top of page

How to Build Confidence in Children: Why Support, Predictability, and Choice Matter

Nov 3
12 min read
Parent and child engaging in a activity together

Parents often encourage their children to "be brave," "just try it," or "stop worrying so much." These comments usually come from a place of wanting children to succeed, develop independence, and recognize their own capabilities. However, confidence does not necessarily develop because a child is told to feel confident or because an adult insists that a situation is not something to worry about.


Imagine a child standing outside a birthday party, refusing to go inside. Earlier in the week, they were excited about attending and talked about seeing their friends. Now that they have arrived, the noise, unfamiliar environment, and uncertainty about what will happen next feel overwhelming.


One parent might respond by saying, "You're fine. Just go inside. Everyone else is already playing." Another might acknowledge that the environment feels overwhelming and offer to walk inside together or spend a few minutes watching what is happening before joining the group.


Both parents want their child to participate, but the approaches provide very different levels of support.


Confidence is more likely to develop when children experience supportive relationships, understand what to expect, and have opportunities to make manageable choices while navigating challenges. Rather than expecting children to become independent simply by removing support, parents can help them gradually develop the skills and experiences that contribute to confidence.


Confidence Develops Through Experience


Children build confidence partly through experiences that allow them to recognize their own capabilities. Psychologist Albert Bandura (1997) described self-efficacy as a person's belief in their ability to organize and carry out the actions necessary to manage particular situations. One important source of self-efficacy is mastery experience, which occurs when individuals successfully navigate challenges and recognize the role their own actions played in the outcome.


For children, these experiences happen throughout everyday life. Ordering their own food at a restaurant, joining a new activity, asking a teacher for help, learning to ride a bicycle, or solving a disagreement with a friend can all provide opportunities to develop confidence.


These experiences are meaningful because children are not simply being told that they are capable. They are developing an understanding of their abilities through their own experiences.


However, the level of difficulty matters. When a challenge feels completely overwhelming, a child may become so focused on managing their distress that they have little opportunity to practice the skill or recognize their progress. When the challenge is manageable and appropriate support is available, children are better positioned to participate, problem-solve, and gradually develop independence.


This is why building confidence often involves finding a balance between providing support and allowing children opportunities to work through challenges themselves.


Why Supportive Relationships Matter


Children are often more willing to explore unfamiliar situations when they know that support is available if they need it. Attachment research has emphasized the importance of caregivers serving as a secure base from which children can explore their environments while having a reliable source of comfort and reassurance (Bowlby, 1988).


This does not mean parents need to prevent discomfort or intervene whenever a child becomes frustrated. Instead, supportive relationships can provide children with the security needed to approach situations that initially feel unfamiliar or challenging.


Consider a child learning to swim. Initially, they may only feel comfortable entering the water while holding a parent's hand. As they become more familiar with the environment, they might begin standing independently in the shallow end, practicing with an instructor, or attempting new skills.


The parent's presence does not necessarily interfere with independence. In many situations, knowing that support is available can make it easier for children to take the next step.


The same process can occur during school transitions, social interactions, extracurricular activities, and everyday challenges. When children feel supported, they may be better able to direct their attention toward learning and participation rather than becoming overwhelmed by uncertainty.


Predictability Helps Children Feel More Prepared


Adults sometimes underestimate how much uncertainty children encounter during ordinary activities. Children are regularly expected to enter unfamiliar environments, interact with new people, follow changing schedules, transition between activities, and respond to expectations they may not fully understand.


For children who experience anxiety, sensory sensitivities, or difficulty with transitions, uncertainty can make participation particularly challenging. Providing predictability helps children understand what they are walking into and what will be expected of them. For example, if a child is nervous about starting a new extracurricular activity, a parent might explain where the activity will take place, who will be there, what the first few minutes will look like, and when they will return.


Looking at pictures of the location, visiting beforehand when possible, or practicing part of the routine at home may also help the child become more familiar with the experience.


Research has identified intolerance of uncertainty as a factor associated with anxiety symptoms in children and adolescents (Osmanağaoğlu et al., 2018). Although providing information cannot eliminate all uncertainty, it may help children approach unfamiliar situations with a greater sense of preparation.


It is also important to recognize that predictability does not mean promising that everything will happen exactly as planned. Children benefit from learning that unexpected changes can occur and that they can receive support while adjusting to those changes.


The goal is to provide enough structure that children feel prepared while gradually helping them develop flexibility when circumstances change.


Manageable Choices Help Children Develop Autonomy


Children spend much of their day having decisions made for them. Adults determine when they wake up, where they go, what activities they attend, and how their schedules are organized.

Many of these decisions are necessary, but they also mean children have relatively limited opportunities to practice making choices.


Offering manageable choices allows children to experience some control within appropriate boundaries.


Self-determination theory identifies autonomy, competence, and relatedness as important psychological needs associated with motivation and well-being (Ryan & Deci, 2000). Providing opportunities for children to make decisions can support their developing sense of autonomy while allowing them to practice problem-solving and decision-making skills.


For example, rather than telling a child to get ready for school and expecting immediate compliance, a parent might say, "It's time to get ready. Would you like to put on your shoes first or your jacket first?" The expectation remains the same because the child still needs to get ready for school. However, the child has an opportunity to make a decision about how to approach the task.


Other examples might include allowing children to choose between two appropriate outfits, decide which homework assignment to complete first, select a coping strategy, or determine whether they want a parent nearby while practicing a new skill.


These choices may seem small from an adult perspective, but they provide meaningful opportunities for children to develop confidence in their ability to make decisions.


Why Too Many Choices Can Be Overwhelming


While offering choices can support autonomy, providing too many options can create additional stress. For example, asking a young child what they want to do for the entire afternoon may be overwhelming because the question requires them to consider numerous possibilities. Offering a choice between going to the playground or riding their bicycle provides structure while still allowing the child to participate in the decision.


Children who struggle with anxiety, executive functioning, or emotional regulation may particularly benefit from choices that are clear, limited, and developmentally appropriate.


Parents should also avoid presenting expectations as choices when the decision is not actually optional. Asking a child whether they want to attend school may create confusion if staying home is not an available option. Instead, parents can offer choices about the parts of the routine that are flexible, such as what music to listen to on the way or whether to walk into the building with a trusted adult.


When predictability and autonomy are combined, children have opportunities to make decisions without being responsible for managing situations that exceed their developmental capabilities.


Confidence Does Not Mean Children Never Feel Afraid


One common misconception is that confident children are not anxious, hesitant, or afraid. In reality, children can experience nervousness while still demonstrating confidence through their willingness to approach a challenge.


A child may feel anxious about raising their hand in class but decide to try. Another may feel uncertain about joining a new group but enter the room with support. A child learning to ride a bicycle may continue worrying about falling even after successfully riding several times.


These experiences demonstrate that confidence does not require the complete absence of fear.

Parents can help children understand that uncomfortable emotions and personal capability can exist at the same time. Instead of trying to convince a child that there is nothing to worry about, it may be more helpful to acknowledge the emotion while identifying a manageable next step.


For example, a parent might say, "I understand that you're nervous about talking to your teacher. Let's practice what you want to say so you feel more prepared."


This approach communicates that the child's feelings are understood while also reinforcing their ability to work toward something difficult.


The Difference Between Encouragement and Pressure


Parents naturally want their children to succeed, and it can be difficult to watch a child hesitate or avoid something that seems manageable from an adult perspective. Sometimes this frustration leads to pressure, particularly when parents are concerned that avoiding a situation will make future participation more difficult.


A child might hear comments such as, "You're too old to be acting like this," "Your sister can do it," or "You have nothing to be afraid of." Although these statements may be intended to motivate, they can also leave children feeling embarrassed, misunderstood, or increasingly anxious about their performance.


Supportive encouragement acknowledges the difficulty while communicating confidence in the child's ability to make progress. For example, if a child is nervous about asking a teacher for help, a parent might practice the conversation with them before encouraging them to try independently.


The expectation that the child will eventually develop the skill remains, but the adult provides support that makes the experience more manageable.


Research examining parenting and childhood anxiety has identified associations between certain parenting behaviors and anxiety symptoms, although these relationships are complex and do not establish that parenting behaviors alone cause childhood anxiety (McLeod et al., 2007).


A supportive approach allows parents to encourage growth while remaining responsive to their child's emotional and developmental needs.


Why Forcing Independence Can Be Counterproductive


There is an important difference between helping a child gradually become more independent and abruptly removing support before they are prepared to manage a situation. Imagine a child who is anxious about attending a new after-school program. A parent may believe that the child needs to develop independence and decide that dropping them off without preparation is the best approach. For some children, this may work well. For others, the experience may feel overwhelming and increase anxiety about returning the following day.


A more supportive approach might involve visiting the program beforehand, meeting the staff, explaining the routine, and gradually increasing the child's participation.


Evidence-based cognitive behavioral treatments for childhood anxiety often incorporate gradual exposure to help children approach feared situations in manageable steps (Kendall et al., 2008). These interventions are carefully planned and responsive to the child's needs rather than relying on overwhelming experiences to produce independence.


It is important to distinguish between supporting children through manageable discomfort and requiring them to remain in situations that exceed their ability to cope.


Children can learn to tolerate uncertainty and develop independence while still receiving appropriate emotional support.


Allow Children to Experience Manageable Frustration


Supporting children does not mean preventing them from experiencing frustration, disappointment, or mistakes. Learning new skills often involves moments when something does not work as expected, and these experiences can provide opportunities to develop persistence and problem-solving skills.


A child learning to tie their shoes may become frustrated when the laces repeatedly come undone. Another child may struggle to complete a puzzle or become upset when they lose a game.


Parents may feel tempted to immediately solve the problem, complete the task, or remove the source of frustration. Although intervention is sometimes necessary, stepping in too quickly can reduce opportunities for children to practice working through challenges.


Instead, parents can help children identify what is difficult, consider possible solutions, and decide whether they need a break before trying again.


If a child becomes increasingly overwhelmed, additional support may be appropriate. The goal is to maintain a level of challenge where the child can continue learning rather than expecting them to push through distress regardless of its intensity.


Over time, these experiences can help children recognize that frustration does not necessarily mean they are incapable of succeeding.


Confidence and Compliance Are Not the Same Thing


Children who immediately follow directions, enter unfamiliar situations without hesitation, or agree to every request may appear confident. However, compliance and confidence are not necessarily the same thing.


Some children are naturally comfortable with unfamiliar situations and enjoy trying new experiences. Others may comply because they worry about disappointing adults, getting in trouble, or being perceived as difficult.


A child who communicates that they are uncomfortable or asks for additional support may be demonstrating an important aspect of confidence: the ability to recognize and express their needs. Developing confidence involves more than participating in activities or meeting adult expectations. It also includes learning to communicate preferences, ask questions, seek help, and establish appropriate boundaries.


These skills are particularly important when teaching children about personal safety and healthy relationships.


Parents can encourage children to try new things while also reinforcing that they are allowed to speak up when something feels uncomfortable or unsafe.


Everyday Ways Parents Can Help Children Build Confidence


Building confidence does not require elaborate activities or structured lessons. Many opportunities occur naturally throughout everyday routines, particularly when parents allow children to participate in decisions and work through manageable challenges.


For example, if a child is nervous about ordering food at a restaurant, a parent might begin by having the child tell them what they want. As the child becomes more comfortable, they could practice speaking directly to the server with the parent nearby.


If a child feels anxious about attending a birthday party, the parent might explain what to expect, identify familiar people who will be there, and create a plan for entering the gathering.


When a child becomes frustrated while learning a new skill, parents can acknowledge the difficulty while helping them identify possible next steps rather than immediately completing the task for them.


These everyday experiences provide opportunities to practice communication, emotional regulation, problem-solving, and independence.


It is also helpful to recognize that progress may not be consistent. A child who successfully manages a situation one day may struggle with something similar another day because of fatigue, stress, illness, or other factors.


Confidence develops over time through repeated experiences rather than following a perfectly predictable progression.


Focus on Effort, Strategies, and Progress


The way adults respond to children's efforts can influence how children approach challenges and interpret setbacks.


Research examining praise has found that emphasizing intelligence or fixed personal traits can sometimes contribute to less adaptive responses when children encounter difficulties, whereas feedback focused on effort and learning processes may support more constructive approaches (Mueller & Dweck, 1998).


Instead of focusing exclusively on whether a child succeeded, parents can recognize the strategies and behaviors that contributed to their progress.


For example, a parent might acknowledge that a child continued trying different approaches to solve a problem, practiced a difficult conversation before speaking with a teacher, or recognized when they needed a break before returning to an activity.


This type of feedback helps children understand what they did to manage the challenge and reinforces skills they can use in future situations.


It also communicates that mistakes and setbacks are expected parts of learning rather than evidence that they are incapable.


When Children Need Additional Support


Some children experience significant anxiety around unfamiliar situations, transitions, social interactions, or performance expectations. When these difficulties become persistent, they may begin interfering with school participation, friendships, family routines, or activities the child would otherwise enjoy.


A child may regularly avoid new experiences, experience intense distress during transitions, or become overwhelmed by situations that seem manageable for peers of a similar age.

In these circumstances, therapy can help identify what is contributing to the difficulty and develop strategies that match the child's individual needs.


For some children, treatment may involve cognitive behavioral therapy and gradual exposure. For others, support may focus on emotional regulation, sensory needs, executive functioning, parent-child interactions, or increasing predictability in their environments.


The goal is not to make every child outgoing, fearless, or independent in the same way. Instead, therapy can help children develop confidence in their ability to navigate situations that are meaningful to them while recognizing their individual strengths and support needs.


Confidence Grows Through Support, Predictability, and Choice


Children develop confidence through experiences that allow them to recognize their capabilities, make decisions, recover from mistakes, and gradually approach new challenges.


Support and independence do not have to be competing goals. Providing predictability does not prevent children from developing flexibility, and offering manageable choices does not mean removing expectations or boundaries.


When children have supportive relationships, understand what to expect, and are given opportunities to participate in decisions, they can gradually develop the skills needed to approach challenges with greater confidence.


At Premier Psychotherapy, we work with children and families navigating anxiety, emotional regulation, transitions, ADHD, sensory sensitivities, and difficulties with confidence and independence. Through developmentally appropriate therapeutic approaches, including play-based interventions and caregiver collaboration, therapy can help children develop skills while supporting parents in understanding their child's individual needs.


Ultimately, the goal is not to raise children who never experience fear, frustration, or uncertainty. It is to help them develop the confidence to approach challenges, recognize when they need support, and understand that becoming independent does not mean having to manage everything alone.


References

Bandura, A. (1997). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. W. H. Freeman.

Bowlby, J. (1988). A secure base: Parent-child attachment and healthy human development. Basic Books.

Kendall, P. C., Hudson, J. L., Gosch, E., Flannery-Schroeder, E., & Suveg, C. (2008). Cognitive-

behavioral therapy for anxiety disordered youth: A randomized clinical trial evaluating child

and family modalities. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 76(2), 282–297.

McLeod, B. D., Wood, J. J., & Weisz, J. R. (2007). Examining the association between parenting

and childhood anxiety: A meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review, 27(2), 155–172.

Mueller, C. M., & Dweck, C. S. (1998). Praise for intelligence can undermine children's

motivation and performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1), 33–52.

Osmanağaoğlu, N., Creswell, C., & Dodd, H. F. (2018). Intolerance of uncertainty, anxiety, and

worry in children and adolescents: A meta-analysis. Journal of Affective Disorders, 225, 80–

Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic

motivation, social development, and well-being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68–78.


Comments


bottom of page